If you have been arrested for driving under the influence and a breath test was used to determine your blood alcohol content (BAC), it is important to be aware of possible defenses to the use of such a test to prove you guilty of a DUI. Possible defenses include, but are not limited to, the following:
1) Inadequate or broken observation period. In order to properly read your BAC by a breath test, the testing officer must observe you continuously for at least 15 minutes before taking a sample. If you belch, vomit, or regurgitate gas in your mouth before the test, your BAC may read inaccurately high. If the officer has not observed you continuously for 15 minutes prior to measuring your BAC, it will be impossible for him to say that you did contaminate your own breath test.
2) Something in your mouth causes an inaccurate reading. Common items such as cough drops, breath mints, or chewing tobacco may remain in your mouth when a breath test is administered and can contaminate the results.
3) Your own personal medical history. If diagnosed prior to your arrest for DUI, many conditions, such as gastric reflux disease, intestinal problems, diabetes, and respiratory problems, can be used to show the likelihood of an inaccurate BAC reading from a breath test.
4) Your own personal dental history. Gum disease, gingivitis, and pockets around the roots of your teeth, as well as dentures or bridgework may trap alcohol in your mouth and contaminate a breath sample.
5) Your behavior or actions do not match test results. If there are witnesses, video tape, or observations by officers that suggests you were not intoxicated, it may be possible to challenge the readings from a breath test.
6) Rising blood alcohol level. If your first breath sample registers slightly over the legal limit, and a second sample taken later is higher, it is clear your BAC is rising. If this is the case it may be possible to argue that, at the time you were driving, your BAC was not over the legal limit.
7) Inexperience or incompetence of the arresting or testing officer. If the officer who arrested you or took your breath sample is not trained in the proper procedure or fails to follow protocol it may be possible to have the results of the improperly administered breath test thrown out.
8) Accuracy of the breath test machine. An artificially high reading can result from interference with the circuitry of a machine due to radio interference, shared power sources, or smoking in or near the machine.
9) Irregular samples. Consecutive BAC readings that vary a great deal can be used to challenge the accuracy of breath samples.
10) Statutory time limit. The prosecution must prove that the breath sample was obtained within three hours of the time you were driving in order to invoke the presumption that you were intoxicated at the time you were driving.
These are just a few of the many defenses that may be available to you if you have been charged with a DUI on the basis of a breath test. Of course, countless more defenses are available depending on the circumstances of your case. Contact the Law Offices of Scott R. Ball today to discuss your case and determine what defenses may be available for you. As always, a consultation regarding your case is completely free and totally confidential.
8/24/09
VC 23103 Reckless Driving: The What, How, and Why
Reckless driving, defined at Section 23103, is one of the most vaguely worded statutes in the California Vehicle Code. It states that “[a]ny person who drives any vehicle upon a highway in willful or wanton disregard for the safety of persons or property is guilty of reckless driving.” A person found guilty for a first offense of reckless driving can face fines of several thousand dollars, a jail sentence of up to 90 days, their car impounded for up to 30 days, and have their license suspended for a month. A second or third violation of reckless driving, or if someone was injured as a result of a person’s reckless driving, can result in a mandatory license suspension for a year and up to 6 months in jail. A reckless driving is also considered a “discretionary arrest” misdemeanor, meaning the citing officer can merely give you a ticket or arrest you and take you to jail.
A charge of reckless driving is a misdemeanor offense, which, if convicted, will result in a criminal record and two points on your driving record. Generally, two points in any eighteen month period will result in a rise in your car insurance rates. If you have previous points on your record, it could also result in an even longer suspension of your license.
However, if you have been charged with reckless driving, with a skilled attorney, it is very possible to fight and win your case. The vague nature of the phrase “willful and wanton disregard for safety” leaves a great deal of room for a skilled attorney to argue your case either does not merit a misdemeanor charge or should be dismissed entirely. California courts have held that negligence, and even gross negligence, is not enough alone to establish reckless driving. This means that the prosecution must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the driver intentionally did something he knew, or should have known, could result in killing or injuring someone.
Generally, a rule of thumb by police officers is that three moving violations, committed in rapid succession by a driver, constitute reckless driving. However, the courts have not adopted this rule, and follow the statutory definition of “willful and wanton disregard for safety.” This means that it is possible to be cited for reckless driving for committing a single “unsafe” maneuver, as defined by the officer, such as cutting sharply across traffic to make an abrupt turn.
If you have been charged with reckless driving, you should contact a criminal defense attorney today. A skilled attorney may be able to have unfair reckless driving charges completely dismissed, keeping you out of jail and saving your license. Further, it is often possible to have the misdemeanor charge reduced to a mere traffic infraction, which will result in greatly reduced fines and, when combined with traffic school, no points on your record. Contact the Law Offices of Scott R. Ball today for a free and confidential evaluation of your case.
A charge of reckless driving is a misdemeanor offense, which, if convicted, will result in a criminal record and two points on your driving record. Generally, two points in any eighteen month period will result in a rise in your car insurance rates. If you have previous points on your record, it could also result in an even longer suspension of your license.
However, if you have been charged with reckless driving, with a skilled attorney, it is very possible to fight and win your case. The vague nature of the phrase “willful and wanton disregard for safety” leaves a great deal of room for a skilled attorney to argue your case either does not merit a misdemeanor charge or should be dismissed entirely. California courts have held that negligence, and even gross negligence, is not enough alone to establish reckless driving. This means that the prosecution must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the driver intentionally did something he knew, or should have known, could result in killing or injuring someone.
Generally, a rule of thumb by police officers is that three moving violations, committed in rapid succession by a driver, constitute reckless driving. However, the courts have not adopted this rule, and follow the statutory definition of “willful and wanton disregard for safety.” This means that it is possible to be cited for reckless driving for committing a single “unsafe” maneuver, as defined by the officer, such as cutting sharply across traffic to make an abrupt turn.
If you have been charged with reckless driving, you should contact a criminal defense attorney today. A skilled attorney may be able to have unfair reckless driving charges completely dismissed, keeping you out of jail and saving your license. Further, it is often possible to have the misdemeanor charge reduced to a mere traffic infraction, which will result in greatly reduced fines and, when combined with traffic school, no points on your record. Contact the Law Offices of Scott R. Ball today for a free and confidential evaluation of your case.
8/14/09
The Many Ways the DMV Can Suspend Your License
Everyone knows that being arrested for driving under the influence of alcohol can result in the loss of your license, but did you know that there are literally dozens of other ways your license can be suspended? Be aware, here are some ways you can have your license taken away that you may not have realized:
Driving under the influence of ANY drug. The law does not distinguish between illegal and over the counter drugs. This means that if your driving is impaired, you may be arrested for a DUI just as readily from being drowsy from too much NyQuil as being high on cocaine.
Lack of insurance. If you drive in California, you must have a minimum amount of insurance coverage. If you are visiting or just moved to the state, be sure to check with your out-of-state insurance company to confirm they are authorized to do business here.
Refusing to consent to a BAC test. Under California’s implied consent law, by driving a motor vehicle you are agreeing to consent to a chemical test of your breath or blood to determine blood alcohol content.
Failure to appear or pay a traffic ticket. When you sign at the X on a traffic ticket, you are agreeing to pay the fine or appear in court. Failure to do so, even if you never receive anything in the mail, can result in your license being suspended.
Too many points on your record. Four points in one year, six in two years, or eight in three years can result in your license being suspended by the DMV.
Failure to pay child support. If you have failed to pay child support, your license can be suspended, and you may not know why even after you have been arrested.
Vandalism/Graffiti. California law allows the courts to suspend a person’s license for up to two years upon a conviction of vandalism. If the person does not yet have a license, the court may delay the issuance of a license for up to three years.
Possession of firearms or live ammunition. If a minor is convicted of possessing a concealable weapon or live ammunition, the court may revoke or suspend driving privileges.
Other ways your license may be suspended include:
It is important to be aware of the ways in which your license can be suspended so that you can avoid them. Driving on a suspended license is a criminal offense and can be punished by a $1,000 fine and up to six months in jail. However, if you are charged with or are facing one of the above situations, it is important to have an experienced attorney on your side. Contact the Law Offices of Scott R. Ball today for a free and completely confidential evaluation of your case.
Driving under the influence of ANY drug. The law does not distinguish between illegal and over the counter drugs. This means that if your driving is impaired, you may be arrested for a DUI just as readily from being drowsy from too much NyQuil as being high on cocaine.
Lack of insurance. If you drive in California, you must have a minimum amount of insurance coverage. If you are visiting or just moved to the state, be sure to check with your out-of-state insurance company to confirm they are authorized to do business here.
Refusing to consent to a BAC test. Under California’s implied consent law, by driving a motor vehicle you are agreeing to consent to a chemical test of your breath or blood to determine blood alcohol content.
Failure to appear or pay a traffic ticket. When you sign at the X on a traffic ticket, you are agreeing to pay the fine or appear in court. Failure to do so, even if you never receive anything in the mail, can result in your license being suspended.
Too many points on your record. Four points in one year, six in two years, or eight in three years can result in your license being suspended by the DMV.
Failure to pay child support. If you have failed to pay child support, your license can be suspended, and you may not know why even after you have been arrested.
Vandalism/Graffiti. California law allows the courts to suspend a person’s license for up to two years upon a conviction of vandalism. If the person does not yet have a license, the court may delay the issuance of a license for up to three years.
Possession of firearms or live ammunition. If a minor is convicted of possessing a concealable weapon or live ammunition, the court may revoke or suspend driving privileges.
Other ways your license may be suspended include:
- Engaging in prostitution in a vehicle within 1000 feet of a residence.
- Engaging in a “speed contest” i.e. drag racing against another person or a clock.
- Assaulting a driver, passenger, bicyclist, or pedestrian on a highway. (“Road Rage”)
- Failure to stop at a railway grade crossing.
- Recklessly fleeing a law enforcement officer.
- Leaving the scene of an accident or injury without filing a report.
It is important to be aware of the ways in which your license can be suspended so that you can avoid them. Driving on a suspended license is a criminal offense and can be punished by a $1,000 fine and up to six months in jail. However, if you are charged with or are facing one of the above situations, it is important to have an experienced attorney on your side. Contact the Law Offices of Scott R. Ball today for a free and completely confidential evaluation of your case.
8/11/09
HELP! I Was Arrested for a DUI! What Do I Do Now?
If you have recently been arrested and charged with driving under the influence in California, it is important to realize that time is of the essence. Your first action should probably be to contact a good criminal defense attorney. However, regardless of if and when you decide to contact an attorney, there are several important things of which you should be aware.
When you are arrested for a DUI, there are two separate and independent proceedings that are set in motion, both with the ultimate goal of punishing you. Obviously, there will be criminal charges, which will take place in the Superior Court in the jurisdiction in which you were arrested. However, there will also be a separate proceeding with the Department of Motor Vehicles where a determination will be made if your license is to be suspended.
Immediately after you are arrested the most important thing for you to do, short of obtaining a skilled attorney, is to contact the DMV’s Office of Driver Safety and request a hearing to challenge the suspension of your license. This MUST be done within 10 calendar days, or your license will automatically be suspended. The U.S. Constitution requires “due process” before your driver’s license is taken away. This means the DMV must notify you of a proposed suspension and allow you a chance to challenge the suspension.
At the hearing, you will have the opportunity to show that a suspension (or revocation) is not justified. Even if you are later acquitted by the criminal court, this hearing is the ONLY time you will be able to prevent your license from being automatically suspended.
It is important to note that since the DMV proceeding is independent from the criminal charges, if you are assigned a public defender, he or she will NOT represent you in a hearing to challenge your suspended license. Unless you retain a private attorney, you will be completely on your own trying to save your driving privileges. While it is possible to win a DMV hearing on your own, an attorney familiar with the proceeding will give you the absolute best chance to save your license.
Further, even if you lose your DMV hearing, an experienced attorney can take advantage of the proceeding by using it to obtain a favorable ruling in the later criminal charges, including possibly a dismissal. For example, by tape recording the DMV hearing, a skilled attorney may be able to later impeach a testifying officer and call into question his or her credibility. If you want to learn more about your case, contact the Law Offices of Scott R. Ball today. Any consultation is totally free and always completely confidential.
When you are arrested for a DUI, there are two separate and independent proceedings that are set in motion, both with the ultimate goal of punishing you. Obviously, there will be criminal charges, which will take place in the Superior Court in the jurisdiction in which you were arrested. However, there will also be a separate proceeding with the Department of Motor Vehicles where a determination will be made if your license is to be suspended.
Immediately after you are arrested the most important thing for you to do, short of obtaining a skilled attorney, is to contact the DMV’s Office of Driver Safety and request a hearing to challenge the suspension of your license. This MUST be done within 10 calendar days, or your license will automatically be suspended. The U.S. Constitution requires “due process” before your driver’s license is taken away. This means the DMV must notify you of a proposed suspension and allow you a chance to challenge the suspension.
At the hearing, you will have the opportunity to show that a suspension (or revocation) is not justified. Even if you are later acquitted by the criminal court, this hearing is the ONLY time you will be able to prevent your license from being automatically suspended.
It is important to note that since the DMV proceeding is independent from the criminal charges, if you are assigned a public defender, he or she will NOT represent you in a hearing to challenge your suspended license. Unless you retain a private attorney, you will be completely on your own trying to save your driving privileges. While it is possible to win a DMV hearing on your own, an attorney familiar with the proceeding will give you the absolute best chance to save your license.
Further, even if you lose your DMV hearing, an experienced attorney can take advantage of the proceeding by using it to obtain a favorable ruling in the later criminal charges, including possibly a dismissal. For example, by tape recording the DMV hearing, a skilled attorney may be able to later impeach a testifying officer and call into question his or her credibility. If you want to learn more about your case, contact the Law Offices of Scott R. Ball today. Any consultation is totally free and always completely confidential.
8/6/09
"Probation" Explained
You’ve probably met or heard of a person who is “on probation” but have you ever wondered what that actually means? Well, depending on whether the person is on formal or informal probation and the particulars of the crime, it could mean any number of different terms to each individual.
Formal, or “supervised” probation, is the more serious form. Formal probation requires the individual sentenced to make regular reports to a probation officer. Informal probation, also known as a “summary” or “court” probation, or “conditional sentence,” does not require the individual to make regular reports to a probation officer. Both kinds of probation, however, can subject an individual to the loss of many freedoms.
Often, probation is given in lieu of a jail or prison sentence. At the time of conviction, if a defendant is eligible for probation, the judge may either impose a sentence and then suspend the execution of that sentence, or may suspend imposing the sentence at all, in favor of granting probation. Probation consists of a fixed term during which the probationer must abide by the terms set by the court or probation officer. If the probationer breaks his or her probation, for example by committing another crime or failing a drug test, he or she will be subject to the sentence that was suspended by the court at the time probation was granted. This means if you screw up your probation, you are almost assuredly going to jail.
The court or probation officer have broad discretion to impose any “reasonable conditions” necessary to secure justice and assist the “reformation and rehabilitation” of the probationer, as long as the conditions are reasonably related to the offense and aimed at deterring such misconduct in the future. These terms include things like mandatory alcohol or drug testing, community service, counseling, curfews for minors, stay-away orders, electronic monitoring, home detention, travel restrictions, or suspension of a driver’s license.
Probation might not sound like very much fun, but it is often a welcome alternative to jail time. If you are facing a potential conviction on criminal charges, it is important you have an experienced attorney to negotiate on your behalf. A skilled attorney familiar with the judge and district attorney in your case can arrange for probation instead of jail, and will be able to get the best possible terms. Contact the Law Offices of Scott R. Ball today for a free and confidential evaluation of your case.
Formal, or “supervised” probation, is the more serious form. Formal probation requires the individual sentenced to make regular reports to a probation officer. Informal probation, also known as a “summary” or “court” probation, or “conditional sentence,” does not require the individual to make regular reports to a probation officer. Both kinds of probation, however, can subject an individual to the loss of many freedoms.
Often, probation is given in lieu of a jail or prison sentence. At the time of conviction, if a defendant is eligible for probation, the judge may either impose a sentence and then suspend the execution of that sentence, or may suspend imposing the sentence at all, in favor of granting probation. Probation consists of a fixed term during which the probationer must abide by the terms set by the court or probation officer. If the probationer breaks his or her probation, for example by committing another crime or failing a drug test, he or she will be subject to the sentence that was suspended by the court at the time probation was granted. This means if you screw up your probation, you are almost assuredly going to jail.
The court or probation officer have broad discretion to impose any “reasonable conditions” necessary to secure justice and assist the “reformation and rehabilitation” of the probationer, as long as the conditions are reasonably related to the offense and aimed at deterring such misconduct in the future. These terms include things like mandatory alcohol or drug testing, community service, counseling, curfews for minors, stay-away orders, electronic monitoring, home detention, travel restrictions, or suspension of a driver’s license.
Probation might not sound like very much fun, but it is often a welcome alternative to jail time. If you are facing a potential conviction on criminal charges, it is important you have an experienced attorney to negotiate on your behalf. A skilled attorney familiar with the judge and district attorney in your case can arrange for probation instead of jail, and will be able to get the best possible terms. Contact the Law Offices of Scott R. Ball today for a free and confidential evaluation of your case.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
